Saturday, July 10, 2021

We are not Athenians, so Why Democracy?


Plato defined five political forms:  AristocracyTimocracyOligarchyDemocracy, and TyrannyHe did not recommend democracy, which is the rule of the cognitively challenged masses. Israel's Supreme Court approved the Nationality Law, directed to restrict the immigration of non-Jews. The reason: it is compatible with democracy. Is that a valid reason? Why we need democracy? Is it feasible in a multinational multiracial polity? Our ancestors adopted theocracy, the rule of the cohanim, a hereditary priestly caste, Israel and Judea were for a long time elective Kingdoms, then for a few generations hereditary kingdoms. Those were typical Middle Eastern forms, like the theocracy in Iran and the Hashemite Kingdom in Jordan. Why should we adopt foreign, pagan, Greek forms? 

No comments:

Post a Comment